How to Tell If a Used Gaming Console Is Worth Buying

So, you’ve decided to dive into the world of used gaming consoles. Maybe you want to relive your childhood with a classic PlayStation 2, or perhaps you’re hunting for a last-gen PS5 because, let’s be real, new ones are still way too expensive. Whatever your reason, buying a secondhand console can be a goldmine—or a glitchy, dust-filled disaster waiting to happen.

But fear not! I’m here to walk you through the crucial checkpoints to ensure you don’t end up with a console that’s as broken as your opponent’s spirit after a well-timed headshot. Let’s get into it.

1. Check the Price—Does It Make Sense?

First things first: if the deal sounds too good to be true, it probably is. A brand-new Xbox Series X still goes for around $500, so if someone’s selling one for $100, you might want to ask some questions. Like, “Why is it haunted?” or “Does it come with missing parts?” Compare the price to other listings and make sure it’s in a reasonable range.

Pro Tip:

Use eBay’s Sold Listings feature to see what similar consoles have actually sold for. If your deal is way off, it’s time to investigate further.

2. Ask About the Console’s History (And Hope It’s Not a Tragic One)

Would you buy a used car without asking about its accident history? Hopefully not. The same logic applies to gaming consoles. Ask the seller about:

  • Age of the console – Older doesn’t always mean bad, but it does mean you should check it more thoroughly.

  • Previous issues – Has it overheated? Has it been repaired before?

  • Usage – Was it owned by a casual gamer or someone who spent 12 hours a day grinding in Elden Ring?

3. Inspect the Exterior—A Little Dirt is Fine, But...

A few smudges and dust bunnies? No big deal. But if it looks like it’s been through a war zone, you might want to reconsider. Look out for:

  • Cracks, dents, or deep scratches – These could indicate the console was dropped (maybe multiple times).

  • Missing parts – Are the buttons all there? Is the disc drive intact? If it’s a cartridge-based console, are the pins in good condition?

  • Funky smells – If it smells like smoke, mold, or a mysterious odor you can’t quite place, you might end up with a console that’s been through some... things.

4. Check the Controllers—Drift is Real

Joy-Con drift, sticky buttons, or unresponsive triggers can turn your gaming experience into a nightmare. If the console comes with controllers, test them out.

What to check:

  • Do all buttons work?

  • Is there any drift in the analog sticks?

  • Do the triggers and bumpers click properly?

  • Is there weird, sticky residue? (Gross.)

If the controller is a mess, replacements can be pricey—factor that into your budget.

5. Power It Up—Does It Actually Work?

If possible, always test the console before buying. Watch out for:

  • Powering issues – Does it turn on instantly, or does it struggle?

  • Display problems – Any weird graphical glitches?

  • Overheating – If it gets hotter than a summer sidewalk in Arizona after five minutes, it’s a bad sign.

  • Loud fan noise – Some consoles are naturally loud (looking at you, PS4), but excessive noise could mean dust buildup or internal issues.

6. Check Online for Common Issues

Some consoles have notorious problems. Do a quick Google search for common hardware failures. For example:

  • Xbox 360 – The dreaded Red Ring of Death.

  • PS4 – Overheating and loud fans.

  • Nintendo Switch – Joy-Con drift.

  • PS5 – Coil whine (annoying, but not always a dealbreaker).

Knowing the risks can help you identify potential red flags before you buy.

7. Look at the Warranty (Or Lack Thereof)

If you’re buying from a store, check if there’s any return policy or warranty. Many secondhand electronics stores offer at least a short-term guarantee. If you’re buying from a random person online, assume it’s “as-is” and proceed with caution.

8. Consider the Digital vs. Physical Factor

Some newer consoles, like the PlayStation 5 Digital Edition and Xbox Series S, don’t have disc drives. Make sure you’re okay with a digital-only console before buying. Also, if you’re getting an older system, check if it supports backward compatibility with your favorite games.

9. Is It Banned? (Yes, That’s a Thing)

For online gaming, check if the console is banned from services like Xbox Live or PlayStation Network. A console ban means you can’t play online, which could be a dealbreaker if multiplayer is your thing. Ask the seller directly, or, if you can, test it yourself by logging into an account.

10. Factor in Extra Costs

A “cheap” console isn’t so cheap if you have to buy extra parts to make it usable. Consider:

  • Controllers – If none are included, you’ll need to buy one.

  • Power cables & HDMI – Missing cables = more money spent.

  • Storage upgrades – Some older consoles need expanded storage for modern games.

  • Games – If it doesn’t come with games, how much will you spend to build a decent library?

Final Verdict: Buy or Bye?

If the console passes these tests, congratulations! You’ve found yourself a solid used gaming system. If not? Run. Run far, far away.

A little research and patience can save you from wasting your money on a console that’s one loading screen away from the afterlife. Happy hunting, and may your deals be legendary!

Back to blog