How to Trade in Old Games for Maximum Value (and Maybe Even Profit!)

Gaming is a wild ride. One moment, you're immersed in an epic quest, conquering digital worlds, and the next, your once-beloved games are collecting dust on a shelf like forgotten relics of a bygone era. But wait! Those games might be worth more than just nostalgia. If you play your cards right, you can trade them in for serious value—or even flip them for a profit. Here’s how to do it like a pro!

1. Know What Your Games Are Worth

Before rushing to trade in your old games, do some detective work. Prices fluctuate based on demand, rarity, and condition. Use resources like:

  • PriceCharting – See historical price trends.

  • eBay Sold Listings – Find out what people are actually paying.

  • GameStop, Best Buy, and Local Game Shops – Check trade-in values to see if it's even worth the effort.

Pro Tip: Limited editions, sealed copies, and certain retro games can be worth a small fortune. If you’ve got an old copy of EarthBound or Rule of Rose, don’t just trade it in for pennies—sell it strategically!

2. Timing Is Everything

Just like the stock market, the value of used games can rise and fall. If a game has recently been removed from digital stores (looking at you, PT), demand skyrockets. Similarly, when a sequel is announced, older titles in the series often get a value boost.

Best times to trade:

  • Before a major sale event (because game stores want fresh inventory)

  • Before a new console drops (old-gen games might lose value fast)

  • Right before demand spikes (like when an old title gets a remaster announcement)

3. Clean and Complete = More Cash

Trading in a scratched-up, sticker-covered game case is like trying to sell a car with a busted headlight. Presentation matters!

  • Clean the disc/cartridge – A microfiber cloth can work wonders.

  • Include original cases and manuals – A complete package is worth more.

  • Fix minor scratches – DIY kits or professional resurfacing can increase value.

Bonus points if your game still has promo inserts or special edition goodies. Some collectors pay extra for those tiny details!

4. Compare Trade-In Offers

Not all trade-in programs are created equal. Some pay in cash, while others give store credit with bonuses. Here’s a quick rundown:

  • GameStop – Sometimes has extra trade-in promos but offers low base prices.

  • Best Buy – Decent store credit, but limited selection.

  • Local Game Shops – Can be more generous, especially for retro games.

  • Online Marketplaces (eBay, Mercari, Facebook Marketplace) – Often the best cash value but requires patience and effort.

Pro Move: Look for trade-in boost promotions where stores offer an extra percentage for trade-ins. That extra 20-30% can make a huge difference!

5. Bundle for Better Deals

If you’re trading in a console along with games, many retailers will offer bonuses for bulk trades. Instead of selling games one by one, bundling them together can increase your total value.

This works great if you're trading in old-gen gear to upgrade. For example, trading in a PS4 with games when the PS5 first launched often got players huge trade-in credit.

6. Consider the Resale Market

Sometimes, trading in isn’t the best option. Selling your games individually on eBay, Mercari, or Facebook Marketplace can net you more money—especially for rare or in-demand titles.

Here’s when to sell instead of trade:

  • GameStop is offering pennies for your game.

  • Your game is hard to find and in demand.

  • You have a collector’s edition or steelbook version.

Example: If GameStop offers you $3 in trade credit for a game that sells for $20 on eBay, take the extra step and sell it yourself!

7. Flip Smart: Buy Low, Trade High

Want to level up your game-trading hustle? Keep an eye out for cheap game bundles, clearance sales, and thrift store finds. If you spot a game being sold for a few bucks but know it trades in for more, you've just found an easy flip!

Example: You find Red Dead Redemption 2 at a yard sale for $5. If GameStop is running a trade-in promo and offering $20 for it, that’s an easy $15 profit.

8. Trade in at the Right Stores for What You Need

Not all trade-in credit is equal. If you're planning to buy new games, GameStop or Best Buy credit can be worthwhile. But if you just want cash in hand, local game stores or reselling might be the way to go.

Some stores even let you convert trade credit into gift cards for places like Amazon or Walmart, giving you more flexibility.

Final Thoughts: Maximize Your Game’s Value Like a Pro

Trading in old games doesn’t have to feel like highway robbery. With a little research, smart timing, and strategic selling, you can get way more value out of your old collection. Whether you're funding your next gaming adventure, upgrading your console, or just clearing out clutter, knowing how to game the system (pun intended) will always put you ahead!

Now go forth and trade wisely, my fellow gamer!

 

Back to blog